Key West Historic Old Town Food Tour with 5 Authentic Tastings
Recommended by 95% of travelers
Badge of Excellence
Key West, USA
- 2 hours 30 minutes (approx.)
- Group discounts
- Offered in: English
Overview
From local shrimp to the perfect Key lime pie, Key West dining is a food-lover’s dream, but finding authentic flavors can be a challenge in a town packed with touristy restaurants. Discover the very best bites on a gourmet tour that samples a little bit of everything, exploring Key West’s charming neighborhoods, colorful characters, and history along the way.
- Included tastings feature a wide range of flavors
- Discover eateries off the tourist trail
- Visit lesser-known areas for a glimpse of local life
- Convenient departure point in central Key West
What's Included
- Refreshing iced coffee
- Crispy golden conch fritters
- Authentic Cuban specialties
- Decadent chocolate-dipped Key lime pie
- Our exclusive Secret Dish
- Water
- hotel pick and drop off
- guides gratuities
Meeting and Pickup
Meeting point
- 335 Duval St, Key West, FL 33040, USA
We'll meet at 335 Duval St, Key West, FL 33040, USA.
End point
- Mallory Square, Key West, FL 33040, USA
The tour will end at Mallory Square, near the cruise ship docks.
Itinerary
Mel Fisher Maritime Museum (Pass By)
1 Whitehead St (Pass By)
Key West Historic Seaport (Pass By)
1
Mallory Square
30 minutes • Admission Ticket Free
Additional Info
- Confirmation will be received within 48 hours of booking, subject to availability
- Not wheelchair accessible
- Near public transportation
- Infant seats available
- Most travelers can participate
- *We can’t accommodate pets on our food tours*
- Please note: the itinerary and menu is subject to change, based on the locations' availability, weather, and other circumstances.
- Please ensure to contact us in advance of the tour for any dietary requirement, to ensure we can cater for them the best we can.
- This tour involves a fair amount of walking; comfortable shoes are recommended.
- This tour/activity will have a maximum of 12 travelers
Supplied by
Cancellation Policy
You can cancel up to 24 hours in advance of the experience for a full refund.
Traveler Photos
Reviews
4.8
based on 301 reviews
Cathy_W, Apr 2026
The food selections were good in that they were representative of the area. The coffee, and the conch fritters, and key lime pie were excellent and the rum distillery tour and tasting was also fabulous. I have had better Cubans and fish tacos. Although the fish itself and key lime aioli on the taco were tasty, it lacked for additional substance depth. The Cuban was a bit dry.
Our guide was engaging and pleased, but as the title of the tour was "Historic" food tour, I expected more history od the area and how the food tied in with that history and the culture. Going to what locals consider their favorite foodie pics is great, but to go from average to 5 star, more substance is needed. More connecting the dots.
Response from Host, Apr 2026
Thank you for sharing such a thoughtful and detailed review, Cathy. It is great to hear that you enjoyed several parts of the experience, especially the variety of tastings and the time spent with your guide.
Our tours are carefully curated to showcase a range of flavors that represent the area, with a balance of well-loved local favorites and cultural influences. At the same time, your comments about wanting more depth, particularly in how the history connects with the food and overall experience, are well noted. We understand how that added context can elevate a tour from enjoyable to truly memorable.
Feedback like yours plays an important role in how we continue refining our tours. Many guests appreciate the storytelling aspect that ties together food, culture, and history, and we are always working to ensure that connection is as clear and engaging as possible throughout the experience.
We appreciate you joining us and taking the time to share your perspective. We would be glad to have you with us again on another tour and provide an even more complete experience next time.
Edee_G, Mar 2026
A fantastic lesson of Key West history, local food favorites and must-haves, and a great way to learn the "lay of the land." Book this early in your stay, or the must do experience if your stay is short.
Response from Host, Mar 2026
Thank you for sharing your experience with us! It’s always encouraging when guests feel the tour was time well spent. We’d happily host you again on another Secret Food Tours.
Laurie_F, Feb 2026
This experience does not include group seating at restaurants - its first come and first for a seat. We ended up separated from our family to get a seat. Because the entire group was separated the tour guide was not able to talk about the restaurants or foods that much.
Response from Host, Mar 2026
Thank you for sharing your experience on our Key West Historic Old Town Food Tour.
Our tours are designed to reflect how locals enjoy the area, which is why several tastings take place on sidewalks or in more casual settings rather than traditional group seating. This approach helps guests stay immersed in the neighborhood’s atmosphere as the tour moves between stops.
Many guests enjoy this style as it keeps the experience engaging and authentic, though seating at certain locations can vary, especially during busier times. We will also pass along your feedback regarding guide communication, as our guides are known for keeping guests informed with stories and insights throughout each stop.
We appreciate you joining us and hope you were still able to enjoy the range of tastings and the character of Old Town Key West. We would be glad to welcome you on another tour in the future for a different experience!
Sara_T, Feb 2026
First time in Key West and this was the perfect tour to start it off. Kennarose was a phenomenal guide, showed us some great spots and the food/drink stops we're amazing! I'd highly recommend this tour.
We made 6 stops, including coffee, snapper taco, best Cuban sandwich, conch fritter, rum tasting and key lime pie.
Response from Host, Mar 2026
Thanks for sharing this with us! Glad you had a good time overall. We’d love to welcome you on another Secret Food Tours.
Lonnie_C, Feb 2026
Our tour guide John was excellent. Very knowledgeable and informative. I would highly recommend this tour.
Response from Host, Feb 2026
Your comments provide valuable insight for our team. Knowing the tour flow felt well structured is very encouraging. We hope to see you again on Secret Food Tours!
Tom_S, Feb 2026
Come hungry. Food was fantastic, Kennarose was a real treat and made the Tour so enjoyable. Walking was easy due to the numerous stops.
Response from Host, Feb 2026
We’re thankful you shared your thoughts. Knowing our guide helped make the experience approachable is always nice to read. We’d be glad to host you on another Secret Food Tours!
Sue_F, Feb 2026
We had the old town food tour. Our guide was John. His knowledge of the history Key West was amazing. It’s obvious that he loves what he does and wants to share it with tourists. He had great rapport with all of the proprietors at each stop on the food tour. We saw places and restaurants we likely would have missed. Class act. Prepared and professional. Worth every penny.
Response from Host, Feb 2026
We appreciate you leaving a positive review and rating. Taking the time to do that helps other guests know what to expect and supports our local teams. You’re always welcome to join another Secret Food Tours!
Paula_W, Jan 2026
Kenna was very knowledgeable and upbeat. She showed equal concern for each attendee and served us at every tasting. Thank you, Kenna.
Response from Host, Jan 2026
We appreciate your feedback! It’s good to hear the experience felt steady and enjoyable, with food and guidance working well together. You’re invited to discover another Secret Food Tours in any destination.
lpilnick64, Jan 2026
This was my 2nd secrets food tour and it did not disappoint. John Dewitt was a great guide. He is so friendly and knowledgeable about key west. The food we had at each stop was great and I was so full when we were done. I highly recommend this tour.
Response from Host, Jan 2026
Thank you for sharing your thoughts! We’re glad the experience stayed engaging and easy to enjoy throughout. You’re always welcome to explore another Secret Food Tours.
James_W, Dec 2025
It was a good visit with several restaurants. The food was good. Keep in mind however that there are other food tours that are cheaper.
Response from Host, Dec 2025
Thank you for sharing your experience. We’re pleased the tour helped connect local flavors with everyday life in the area. You’re always welcome to discover another Secret Food Tours!
Stefanie_N, Dec 2025
Deanna was a terrific tour guide! Knowledgeable and fun. The food was delicious, the drinks were suburb, and the range of local foods we tried was terrific. Deanna gave us a bit of history in between stops, which was a fun way to learn more about Key West. I definitely recommend!
Response from Host, Dec 2025
Food works best when it reflects its surroundings. We’re glad the tour highlighted that relationship. You’re invited to explore another Secret Food Tours on your next trip!
michele_m, Dec 2025
The tour guide Deanna was great. She took us to out of the way places we wouldn’t have gone to or found as tourist. We enjoyed to tour but it’s extremely expensive for what you get. We do food tours everywhere we travel and none have been this expensive and most of them included liquor.
Response from Host, Dec 2025
Thank you for sharing your feedback and for joining our Key West Historic Old Town Food Tour. We are glad that Deanna made the experience enjoyable and introduced you to local places you would not have found on your own. That local insight and access are elements many guests consistently highlight in their reviews.
Regarding pricing, the tour reflects small group sizes, multiple authentic tastings, and partnerships with independently owned businesses in one of the most visited and higher cost destinations in the country. Many guests feel the value comes from the quality of the food, the walk through Old Town, and the depth of local history shared along the way.
Still, we appreciate you taking the time to share your perspective and would be happy to welcome you again on another tour in the future, whether in Key West or one of our many other destinations.
Marc_G, Dec 2025
Lots of spots we wouldn't find on our own. We really enjoyed the beach stop and Cuban sandwich. Lots of local flavor.
Response from Host, Dec 2025
Thank you for sharing your thoughts with us. We’re glad the tour added clarity to what you were tasting and where you were tasting it. You’re invited to explore another Secret Food Tours on future travels!
Kathleen_M, Dec 2025
It was great! John was our tour guide and you can tell he just loves Key West. All the foods we tried were iconic to Key West. Made me fall in love with the city itself.
Response from Host, Dec 2025
Food can anchor an experience when it’s explained properly. We’re glad the tour delivered that clarity. You’re always welcome to join another Secret Food Tours!
Robyn_W, Dec 2025
Guide was knowledgeable and entertaining! Food was delicious with great options. Only negative feedback would be to ensure there are restroom opportunities as several places did not have.
Response from Host, Dec 2025
Thank you for the wonderful review and for joining our tour. We are delighted to hear that you enjoyed the experience, found the food selections memorable, and appreciated the guide’s knowledge and delivery.
Your note regarding restroom access is very helpful. While we aim to plan the route with appropriate facilities in mind, there are occasions when certain stops may not offer them. We will review the itinerary to strengthen our options and ensure clearer communication during the tour.
We truly appreciate your feedback and your perfect rating. We hope to welcome you back on another tour soon.
christina_s, Oct 2025
Wonderful tour and walk through historic Key West. Our guide was knowledgeable about the area; full of fun stories and local insight. We where able to taste a variety of local foods. All of which where delicious. Definitely recommend.
Response from Host, Oct 2025
Thanks so much for joining us and for leaving this note. We love that you enjoyed the flavors and stories, because that’s what really makes a city come alive. Secret Food Tours would be happy to show you around again anytime!
Scott_D, Oct 2025
A great way to see Key West , our guide was excellent. She was very knowledgeable of the scene in town and was great to experience the town from a locale point of view. A must do !
Response from Host, Oct 2025
Thanks a lot for taking the tour and sharing your thoughts. The best part of what we do is seeing guests enjoy both the food and the company. Secret Food Tours has plenty more waiting in 100+ cities!
Missy_G, Sep 2025
This tour and the tour guide John were amazing! Enjoyed everything about it. Would recommend this to anyone wanting to do a food tour.
Response from Host, Sep 2025
We appreciate you taking the time to write. It’s wonderful that both the food and the atmosphere left such a strong impression. Secret Food Tours in over 100 cities invites you back anytime!
Brian_M, Aug 2025
The tour is worth the money. Book it early in your trip to get an idea of what’s offered in Key West. The guy John was knowledgeable and genuinely enjoyed taking us around and explaining the history of Key West as well as the foods. You get a nice amount of everything. Conch, Cuban sandwich, Keylime pie, coffee or juice, and more.
Response from Host, Aug 2025
Thank you for sharing such a positive review. We love helping guests see the city from a new perspective through its cuisine and hidden gems. You can continue the journey with Secret Food Tours in 100+ destinations globally!
Joshua_R, Jul 2025
John was extremely knowledge and professional. Will definitely be doing this tour again when my wife and I come back to Key West
Response from Host, Jul 2025
Thank you for your 5-star review! We’re glad the local flavors and guide’s insight made the experience special for you. We look forward to welcoming you again with Secret Food Tours in any of our 100+ global cities.
Betty_G, May 2025
This tour was great! our guide took us to local spots with great food. And we also went to a place for rum tasting. My group really enjoyed it even though it rained all day. Worth the money!
Response from Host, May 2025
Thank you for taking the time to share this. The flavors, traditions, and culture you explored with us are at the heart of what we do. We invite you to join another delicious adventure with Secret Food Tours in over 100 cities worldwide, Betty!
Joe_M, Apr 2025
Mark was an excellent host. He worked with our suggestions and included a few nice surprises! I would recommend him in the future.
Response from Host, Apr 2025
Thank you for joining us! We love bringing people closer to a city through its flavors, and we’re thrilled you had a fantastic time. If you're looking for more hidden gems, our 100+ destinations worldwide are ready!
Doreen_C, Feb 2025
The food was great and the tour guide Mark took time with us and told us a lot of history about Key West. My husband and I really enjoyed it!
Response from Host, Mar 2025
A city's culture lives in its food, and we’re so happy you got to experience it with us! Thank you for your kind words—we’d love to take you on another mouthwatering adventure in one of our 100+ destinations worldwide.
Mary_H, Jan 2025
Our guide, Mark, was fantastic! We spent three hours winding our way through the streets of key west eating at local establishment, all with delicious food. This was a great tour.
Response from Host, Mar 2025
It was a pleasure having you on the tour! Every guest adds something special to the experience, and we’re so glad you enjoyed every moment. Thank you for your support!
Linda_P, Jan 2025
Great way to taste the best local food and drink. Would highly recommend to those new to Key West!!!
Response from Host, Mar 2025
Your thoughtful words mean so much! We hope you’ll join us again for another delicious adventure.
Lucy_M, Nov 2024
It was Amazing! Highly recommend Chris was our tour guide super fun he is full of history and took us to delicious food stops along our lovely walk!! His magic tricks was a wonderful bonus!
Response from Host, Mar 2025
Your feedback is incredibly rewarding to hear! We take pride in crafting tours that are fun, insightful, and full of great flavors, and it’s wonderful to know you had a great time. Thank you!
Brenda_P, Nov 2024
Our guide Chris was very enthusiastic and well informed. We visited many local restaurants and enjoyed delicious specialties. We certainly didn’t need to eat again that day. Thank you Chris!
Response from Host, Mar 2025
Thank you for your thoughtful review! Every dish and every story is chosen with care, and we’re delighted to know it all came together for an unforgettable experience.
Michelle_S, Nov 2024
Aiden was great! Spending the afternoon with Aiden was like catching up with a friend over food and drinks, and food and drinks and food and drinks. Secret Food Tours is very generous with options and portions. We went to at least 5 locations and every location was delish!! Not so much history, but a delight to hear about life in Key West from a native. Very nice afternoon.
Response from Host, Mar 2025
Your review truly means a lot! We love sharing hidden gems and incredible flavors, and it’s fantastic to hear that you enjoyed them. Hope to see you again soon!
Benjamin_S, Oct 2024
Our tour guide Aidan was amazing! He is a born local conch! The food was delicious for the spots he took us. Would definitely recommend!
Response from Host, Oct 2024
Hello Benjamin, thank you for sharing your experience with us! We're glad you enjoyed the delicious food and got a real taste of Key West. We’d love to welcome you back on another Secret Food Tour soon – there are plenty more flavors to discover!
Rodney_C, Oct 2024
We had high expectations for our 2nd Key West walking food tour but unfortunately this one was overwhelming. Our tour guide Aiden seemed distracted and disinterested and shared little to no information about the city and culture. While we enjoyed a couple of the samples the “drink” of you can call it that was nothing more than a tablespoon of a margarita sample. We still do not know where the “secret” food was. Definitely missed the mark with this one.
Response from Host, Oct 2024
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience with us, Rodney. We always aim to provide a memorable and enriching tour, so we regret that this time it didn’t fully meet your expectations.
We carefully curate our stops to showcase the best of Key West’s culinary offerings—from beloved local classics to hidden gems—while ensuring that portions are well-balanced so guests can comfortably enjoy the entire experience. Our guides, including Aidan, are typically praised for their enthusiasm in sharing Key West's unique food scene and history, with many guests appreciating their deep knowledge and engaging storytelling. It’s unfortunate that you felt the guide’s focus and presentation fell short, and we appreciate your feedback. We'll be reviewing your comments closely to ensure we continue delivering the lively and informative experience we're known for.
We hope you’ll consider joining us again, as many of our guests leave Key West with wonderful memories of both the food and culture we love to share. If you’d like to discuss this further, feel free to reach out to us at info@secrettours.com.
From $108.00
per personup to 24 hours before the experience starts (local time)
Compare Similar Experiences
Current
Key West Historic Old Town Food Tour with 5 Authentic Tastings
301
2 hours 30 minutes
Free Cancellation
From
$108.00
Customers Who Bought This Tour Also Bought
Attractions in Key West, USA
- Mel Fisher Maritime Museum Tours & Tickets
- St. Paul's Key West Episcopal Church Tours & Tickets
- Overseas Highway Tours & Tickets
- Fort Zachary Taylor Tours & Tickets
- Smathers Beach Tours & Tickets
- Key West Cruise Port Tours & Tickets
- Edward B. Knight Pier Tours & Tickets
- Key West Shipwreck Treasure Museum Tours & Tickets
- Harry S. Truman Little White House Tours & Tickets
- Duval Street Tours & Tickets
- Key West Cemetery Tours & Tickets
- Dry Tortugas National Park Tours & Tickets
- Key West Historic District Tours & Tickets
- Hard Rock Cafe Key West Tours & Tickets
- Southernmost Point of the Continental USA Tours & Tickets
- Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuary Tours & Tickets
- Sand Key Reef Tours & Tickets
- Ernest Hemingway Home and Museum Tours & Tickets
More attractions near Key West, USA